The 6 Biggest Mistakes FMCG Companies Make When Hiring (And How to Avoid Them)
By Emilie Gregson, Founder of Signature Career Management
I've spent a significant part of my career working with FMCG businesses, helping them build commercial teams, recruit exceptional people and, ultimately, achieve their growth ambitions. And if there's one thing I've learnt over the years, it's that finding great talent isn't always the hardest part of recruitment. Sometimes, it's the recruitment process itself that gets in the way.
I've worked with some brilliant businesses. Businesses with fantastic products, ambitious growth plans, strong cultures and genuinely exciting opportunities for the right people. Yet even the best businesses can make hiring decisions that unintentionally work against them. It's rarely because they don't care about getting recruitment right. Quite the opposite, in fact. Often, these mistakes come from wanting to be absolutely certain they're making the right decision.
I completely understand that. Hiring is a significant investment, particularly when you're recruiting someone who will be responsible for managing major retail accounts, growing a category, developing a brand or leading a commercial team. But there's a difference between being thorough and creating unnecessary barriers.
Over the years, I've noticed six common mistakes that repeatedly make FMCG recruitment more difficult than it needs to be. And while they might seem relatively minor in isolation, their combined impact on your ability to attract, secure and retain great talent can be significant.
1. Setting Salary Expectations That Don't Reflect the Market
This is probably one of the most common challenges we encounter in FMCG recruitment. A business has a vacancy, they've established a salary band, agreed a budget and created a job description outlining everything they're looking for. The problem is that the candidate they're describing doesn't necessarily exist at the salary they're offering.
Perhaps they're looking for a National Account Manager with experience managing Tesco or Sainsbury's, a proven record of delivering growth, strong commercial negotiation skills and the potential to progress into a leadership role. All perfectly reasonable requirements. But if the salary sits below what those candidates can already command in the FMCG market, the business is immediately limiting its options.
And we need to remember that we're not just competing for candidates who are actively looking for work. Some of the strongest commercial talent is performing brilliantly in their current business. They're valued, they're progressing, and they're not particularly interested in leaving. To convince someone like that to consider an opportunity, there needs to be a compelling reason.
That doesn't always mean offering the highest salary. Career progression, leadership, culture, flexibility and the opportunity to make a genuine impact can all be incredibly powerful motivators. But there does need to be a realistic understanding of what the market looks like and how your overall proposition compares.
My advice would always be to understand the candidate market before finalising a recruitment budget. What are the people you're looking for currently earning? What would motivate them to move? How does your opportunity compare with what they already have? If the budget is fixed, that's absolutely fine, but something else might need to give, whether that's experience, seniority or the scope of the role.
The worst thing you can do is spend three months searching for someone who was never realistically going to accept the package in the first place.
2. Being Too Narrow About Sector Experience
I understand why FMCG businesses value sector experience. If you're a food manufacturer recruiting a National Account Manager, naturally there's an attraction to someone who's worked in food, understands the retailers and can hit the ground running. But I've also seen businesses become so specific about the type of experience they want that they overlook some genuinely exceptional people.
They want someone from food, but not drinks. Someone from branded FMCG, but not own-label. Someone who's worked with Tesco, but experience with other major retailers isn't quite enough. Sometimes, they want someone who's worked for a direct competitor, in an almost identical role, managing an almost identical customer base.
There are certainly situations where specific experience is essential, and I would never suggest compromising on something that genuinely determines whether someone can do the job. But I always encourage clients to ask themselves whether they're hiring someone because they've done the exact job before, or because they have the capability to do it exceptionally well. Those aren't necessarily the same thing.
A brilliant commercial professional coming from a different FMCG category might bring fresh thinking, new relationships, different approaches and experiences that genuinely benefit the business. Equally, someone who's spent years working in a very similar environment might have all the right experience on paper but lack the adaptability, curiosity or ambition needed to take the business forward.
At Signature, we spend a huge amount of time understanding candidates beyond their CVs: their motivations, behaviours, attitudes, values and what they're actually capable of achieving. Experience matters, of course it does, but so does potential. And when businesses become too focused on finding someone who's already done everything they're asking for, they risk overlooking people who could bring something genuinely valuable to the organisation.
My advice is to separate your non-negotiables from your preferences. If retailer experience is genuinely essential, keep it. But does the person really need to have sold biscuits rather than beverages? Sometimes the strongest hire isn't the most obvious one.
3. Having Too Many Interview Stages
I'm a huge advocate for thorough recruitment processes. Hiring someone based on a quick conversation and a good feeling isn't something I'd ever recommend. But equally, there's a point where a thorough interview process becomes unnecessarily complicated, and I think some businesses lose sight of what they're actually trying to achieve.
A first interview with HR, followed by the hiring manager, then the Commercial Director, a presentation, a meeting with the wider team and perhaps one final conversation with the Managing Director. Before you know it, six weeks have passed and the candidate is starting to wonder whether the business actually knows what it's looking for.
I'm not suggesting every FMCG business should reduce its interview process to two conversations. For senior leadership appointments, multiple stakeholders and more detailed assessments can be entirely appropriate. The issue isn't necessarily the number of stages, but whether each stage has a clear purpose. What are you trying to establish at each point? Who genuinely needs to be involved in the decision? Could two stakeholders meet the candidate together rather than arranging separate interviews? And are you assessing something new, or simply asking the same questions in a different room?
Something businesses sometimes forget is that the candidate is evaluating them just as much as they're evaluating the candidate. The interview process gives people an insight into how your business operates. Is it organised? Are decisions made confidently? Do people communicate well? Is there clarity around responsibilities? If the recruitment process feels disjointed, candidates may start questioning what working there would be like.
The strongest recruitment processes are structured, purposeful and respectful of everyone's time. Before you start recruiting, agree who needs to be involved, what each stage is assessing and when you expect to make a decision. Be thorough, absolutely, but make every stage count.
4. Taking Too Long to Give Feedback
This one genuinely frustrates me because it's so avoidable. A candidate has taken time out of their working day, prepared for an interview, researched the business and invested emotionally in the opportunity. They've had what they believe was a really positive conversation, and then they hear nothing.
A few days pass, then a week, sometimes longer. Meanwhile, the hiring manager is busy, someone is on annual leave or an internal conversation hasn't happened yet. All understandable. Businesses are busy places, and recruitment isn't always the only priority. But from the candidate's perspective, silence sends a message, and it's not usually a positive one.
One of the biggest misconceptions in recruitment is that candidates will simply wait while a business makes up its mind. Some will, but the strongest candidates often have other opportunities, even when they're not actively searching. And even if they don't, prolonged silence can change how they feel about your business. Someone who was genuinely excited about joining can become disengaged surprisingly quickly.
I've seen situations where a candidate's enthusiasm has been affected not by the role, the salary or the company itself, but by the experience they've had during recruitment. That's such a shame, particularly when it's something we can influence. You can have the most exciting opportunity in the world, but if someone feels undervalued before they've even joined, you're making it much harder to convince them that your business is the right place for them.
My advice is simple. Set clear expectations around feedback and stick to them. If you can't make a decision immediately, communicate that. If you're waiting for another interview to take place, explain the timeline. You don't always need to have an answer, but you do need to keep people informed.
And remember, the candidate who doesn't get the job today could be a future customer, colleague or advocate for your business. How you treat people matters, regardless of the outcome.
5. Holding Out for the 'Perfect' Candidate
I think most hiring managers have an image in their heads of what their ideal candidate looks like. The right experience, the right personality, the right salary expectations, the right cultural alignment. Someone who can deliver from day one, requires minimal development and has the potential to progress. Wouldn't that be lovely?
But here's the question I often ask clients: are you looking for the best person to do the job, or are you looking for someone who ticks every box on a piece of paper? Because there's a difference.
Of course, there are non-negotiables. Every role has them. But I've seen businesses turn down very capable candidates because they're missing one relatively minor requirement. Perhaps they've managed two major grocery accounts rather than three. Perhaps they haven't worked in quite the right category. Perhaps they haven't had direct line management responsibility yet, despite demonstrating all the qualities needed to become an excellent leader.
And while the business continues searching, the role remains vacant. The existing team absorbs the workload, projects get delayed and commercial opportunities can be missed. Eventually, the business might find someone who ticks more boxes, but have they actually hired someone better? Not necessarily.
This is where understanding the person behind the CV becomes so important. At Signature, we look closely at attitude, character, motivation and capability, alongside relevant experience. Because a candidate who has 80% of the experience but 100% of the attitude, ambition and ability to learn may well outperform someone who looks perfect on paper.
That doesn't mean compromising on quality. It means understanding what quality actually looks like for your business.
I'd encourage hiring managers to identify the three or four capabilities that will genuinely determine success in the role and assess candidates against those, rather than an endless list of desirable experiences. Ask yourself whether the things they're missing can realistically be developed, and whether the strengths they bring could actually make your team better.
Sometimes, the person with the greatest potential is the one worth investing in.
6. Changing the Brief Halfway Through Recruitment
This is another challenge we encounter, and I can understand why it happens. A business starts recruiting for a particular role. The hiring manager has an idea of what they need, a salary has been agreed, and the recruitment process begins. Then, after meeting a few candidates, something changes.
Perhaps they realise they need someone more senior. Perhaps the role needs greater strategic responsibility. Perhaps another stakeholder gets involved and has a completely different view of what the position should look like. Suddenly, the original brief isn't quite right anymore.
I want to be clear that changing your mind isn't necessarily a bad thing. Recruitment can be an incredibly useful exercise in understanding your own business. Sometimes, meeting candidates highlights gaps in the original thinking or reveals capabilities you hadn't considered. And a good recruitment partner should be challenging your brief and sharing market insight throughout the process.
But there's a difference between refining a brief based on new information and fundamentally changing the requirements after weeks of searching. When that happens, the consequences can be significant. Candidates who've invested time in the process may no longer be suitable, the recruitment timeline gets extended, and the business is effectively starting again, often without fully recognising the cost.
There's also a potential impact on your reputation in the candidate market. If people repeatedly hear that a business isn't quite sure what it's recruiting for, they're less likely to feel confident about exploring opportunities there.
My advice would be to spend more time getting the brief right before going to market, and to think beyond the job description. What is the business trying to achieve over the next 12 to 24 months? What problems does this person need to solve? What does success look like? Who needs to contribute to the decision, and are they aligned?
And importantly, is this genuinely the role the business needs, or simply a replacement for the person who previously occupied it?
The more clarity you have at the beginning, the better the recruitment outcome is likely to be.
The Bigger Issue: Recruitment Decisions Have Commercial Consequences
What connects all six of these mistakes is that they're rarely just recruitment problems. They're business problems, and I think that's something that often gets overlooked when businesses are reviewing their hiring processes.
An unrealistic salary can mean months of unsuccessful searching. Overly restrictive requirements can prevent you from accessing exceptional talent. An unnecessarily lengthy interview process can cost you your preferred candidate, while poor communication can damage your employer brand. Holding out for perfection can leave a commercial role vacant while competitors continue moving forward, and an unclear brief can waste time, money and resources.
In FMCG, where businesses are managing challenging margins, changing consumer expectations, retailer relationships and ambitious growth plans, these things matter. A great National Account Manager, Category Manager, Marketing Manageror Commercial Director can have a significant impact on business performance. Equally, leaving those positions vacant, or hiring the wrong person, can have consequences that extend well beyond the recruitment fee.
Recruitment shouldn't simply be about filling an empty seat. It should be about understanding what your business needs to achieve and finding the people who can help you get there. That's where working with specialist FMCG recruiters can make a real difference.
What the Best FMCG Businesses Do Differently
Having worked with FMCG businesses of all shapes and sizes over the years, I've noticed that the strongest hiring outcomes tend to come from businesses that approach recruitment as a partnership. They're open about their challenges, they understand that market conditions might require them to adjust their expectations, and they're willing to consider candidates who bring something different. They make decisions with purpose, communicate openly and recognise that the candidate experience matters.
Most importantly, they're prepared to be challenged. And that's something I feel very strongly about.
If a client asks us to recruit a role at a salary we know is unrealistic, I don't believe we're doing our job properly if we simply agree and start searching. If they're overlooking a brilliant candidate because of an unnecessarily narrow requirement, I'll challenge that too. Not because we want to make recruitment easier for ourselves, but because our responsibility is to help clients make the best possible hiring decisions. Sometimes that means having conversations that aren't necessarily the easiest, and that's absolutely fine.
At Signature Career Management, we've built our business around long-term relationships, genuine FMCG market knowledge and understanding the people behind the job titles. Our role isn't to send over as many CVs as possible and hope something sticks. It's to understand your business, access the right talent, offer honest advice and help you build a team capable of achieving your ambitions.
Because ultimately, the success of a recruitment process shouldn't be measured by how quickly you've filled a vacancy. It should be measured by the impact that person goes on to have in your business.
And getting that right starts long before the first interview.
Are You Planning to Grow Your FMCG Team?
Whether you're recruiting across Sales, Marketing, eCommerce or the wider FMCG supply chain, it's worth understanding what the candidate market really looks like before you begin.
At Signature Career Management, we're always happy to share our market insight, challenge a brief or help you think through the best approach to your next hire.
Because sometimes, the most valuable part of recruitment is the conversation you have before the search even starts.